| Submission |
| Aims and Scope |
| Editorial Board |
| Reviewers |
| Author Guidelines |
| Reviewers Guidelines |
| Peer Review Process |
| Ethics & Malpractice Statement |
| AI Usage Policy |
| Secreening Plagiarism |
| Copyright Notice |
| Article Processing Charge |
| Indexing & Abstracting |
| Article Template [English] |
| Artikel Templat [Indonesia] |
| Recommend Tools |
Reviewers Guidelines
1. General Principles
Reviewers are expected to provide objective, constructive, and confidential assessments of submitted manuscripts. Reviews should focus on the quality, originality, relevance, and scholarly contribution of the manuscript rather than on the authors personally.
Reviewers should evaluate manuscripts fairly and independently, without discrimination based on nationality, gender, institutional affiliation, academic status, or other personal characteristics.
2. Review Criteria
Reviewers are encouraged to consider the following aspects:
- Relevance: Does the manuscript fit the aims and scope of Journal of Development Praxis?
- Originality: Does the manuscript provide an original contribution to development scholarship, policy, or practice?
- Theoretical/Conceptual Foundation: Is the relevant literature and theoretical or conceptual framework adequately addressed?
- Methodology: Are the research methods appropriate, clearly explained, and adequately applied?
- Findings and Analysis: Are the findings clearly presented and appropriately analyzed?
- Discussion and Contribution: Does the manuscript explain the significance of its findings and their implications for development research, policy, or practice?
- Clarity: Is the manuscript logically structured and clearly written?
- Ethics: Does the research comply with relevant ethical standards?
For Conceptual Papers, Review Articles, and Practice-Based Scholarly Contributions, reviewers should consider the specific characteristics and objectives of each manuscript type.
Conceptual Papers
Reviewers should assess whether the manuscript:
- presents a clear and coherent theoretical or conceptual argument;
- demonstrates adequate engagement with relevant literature;
- identifies and addresses an important conceptual or theoretical issue;
- develops a meaningful concept, framework, model, or perspective; and
- explains the implications of its argument for development research, policy, or practice.
Review Articles
Reviewers should assess whether the manuscript:
- has a clearly defined review topic, objective, or research question;
- uses an appropriate and sufficiently transparent review approach;
- engages with relevant and sufficiently comprehensive literature;
- provides a critical synthesis rather than merely summarizing previous studies;
- identifies important themes, debates, gaps, or developments in the literature; and
- provides meaningful implications for future research, policy, or development practice.
Practice-Based Scholarly Contributions
Reviewers should assess whether the manuscript:
- clearly describes the development context, problem, program, intervention, or practice;
- provides sufficient evidence to support its analysis and claims;
- critically reflects on the implementation, outcomes, challenges, and lessons learned;
- connects practical experience with relevant scholarly literature or concepts;
- goes beyond a descriptive account to provide meaningful analytical insights; and
- identifies lessons or implications that may be relevant to development policy, research, or practice beyond the specific case.
3. Reviewer Comments
Reviewers should provide clear and constructive comments that can help authors improve their manuscripts. Comments should distinguish between major issues that affect the validity or contribution of the manuscript and minor issues such as clarity, organization, or grammatical errors.
Reviewers should avoid offensive, dismissive, or personal comments.
4. Confidentiality and Conflict of Interest
Manuscripts under review are confidential and should not be shared or discussed with others without permission from the editor.
Reviewers should disclose any conflict of interest that may affect their impartiality. Reviewers should decline the review if they have a significant personal, professional, institutional, or financial relationship with the authors or the research.
5. Recommendation
After completing the review, reviewers should provide a recommendation to the editor:
- Accept
- Minor Revision
- Major Revision
- Reject
The final editorial decision is the responsibility of the Editor-in-Chief or the editorial team and is not determined solely by the reviewer's recommendation.